Why Am I Confused About Salt?

The confusion over salt's effect on the body is prevalent as conflicting studies and mythologies abound. Is it good or bad? How much is too much? Is pink salt a fad or a healthier choice? And debates are just beginning about the kind of "salt" to which they're referring. Here are some basics to make informed, healthy choices regarding salt intake.

Fact vs Fiction

Many people feel pulled between believing the government's position on salt and the independent researchers and health organization's recommendations. The "salt" mythologies began in the late 1980s with an international study, called "Intersalt" that claimed salt played a major role in increasing blood pressure. Since then, organizations like the Weston A. Price Foundation have argued that the study confused an industrially created product with real salt and that limiting the second most crucial food - next to water - for humans would contribute to a greater risk of catastrophic health outcomes.

Without discriminating between "kinds" of salts and salt's important role in the body (and poorly designed studies that do not account for fructose intake in processed foods) misguided national campaigns against salt have continued in recent years. Increasing the salt confusion, a Wall Street Journal article blared in January 2010 that a national program to reduce dietary salt "could prevent tens of thousands of heart attacks, strokes, and deaths and trim as much as $24 billion from the healthcare tab." The study, a computer simulation, suggested that the impact would be "similar to prevention strategies such as quitting smoking, lowering cholesterol or modest weight loss" as an "effective weapon against high blood pressure and cardiovascular disease."

Mortin Satin, PhD, vice president of The Salt Institute, points out that, "The overwhelming public interest in salt consumption derives from the concern over its perceived universal impact on blood pressure. Unfortunately, this has long been a subject of significant myth-information... With major reductions in salt (more than half the current consumption), 50% of the population will show no effect at all. Considering the relatively small impact of major salt reduction on blood pressure, it is unfortunate that consumers are not aware of all the other negative consequences that occur as a result of dietary salt reduction."

Sally Fallon, president of the Weston A. Price Foundation, responded to the anti-salt initiative by pointing to previous and misguided government campaigns. "We have heard words like this before. In the 1970s, the McGovern Committee on Dietary Goals assured Americans that our ten greatest killers would be resolved by the simple measure of substituting polyunsaturated

oils for animal fats. Now, forty years later, Americans have largely abandoned animal fats for industrial oils, with disastrous consequences-our ten greatest disease killers have only increased, and the pall of disease has now settled on our children as well. At least in the case of saturated fat we have a substitute, albeit a poor one-refined carbohydrates, which the body very efficiently turns into saturated fat. But as far as the body is concerned, there is no substitute for salt."

Why Do We Need Salt?

Salt (sodium chloride) is the most prevalent food substance consumed, second only to water. Essential to all life, the human body's salt-to-water ratio is critical to metabolism. Dr. Satin says sodium ions present in salt are required by the body to perform essential functions, "Salt helps maintain the fluid in our blood cells and is used to transmit information in our nerves and muscles. It is also used in the uptake of certain nutrients from our small intestines. The body cannot make salt and so we are reliant on food to ensure that we get the required intake."


Salt (sodium chloride) is the most prevalent food substance consumed, second only to water.

According to Dr. F. Batmanghelidj in his book, Water: For Health, for Healing, for Life, salt has many health benefits including:

of nerve cells the entire time that the brain cells work from the moment of conception to death.

Salt is obviously beneficial. The problem is that the industrially refined "salt" product used in processed and fast foods is not at all the same as the natural salt the body craves to perform vital functions.

Dangers of a Low-Salt Diet

As the Weston A. Price Foundation states above, the evidence of problems from low-salt diets has mounted in recent years:

Salt is crucial to the body's basic functioning, so much so, one study linked salt intake to the clinical diagnosis and recovery of depression. Researchers found that when rats are deficient in salt, they shy away from activities they normally enjoy. A loss of pleasure in normally pleasing activities is one of the most important features of psychological depression. If salt is a natural mood-elevating substance, it could help explain why so many people are tempted to over-ingest it, say researchers.

Which Salt Is Healthy?

The variety of food products labeled as "salt" in the average grocery story can be overwhelming. The most popular, traditional "table salt" falls into the same category as refined white flour and white sugar. While it may have been healthy in its original form, table salt has been stripped of all of its nutrients.

After being extracted, industrial, refined table-salt-to-be is subjected to a high-heat process that alters the structure of the chemical compound. Chemicals like fluoride, anticaking agents, potassium iodide, and aluminum derivatives are mixed into the salt, which is then bleached to create the recognizable and desired color: white. The end product is a highly industrial, toxic pseudo-food that many think of as "salt". In reality, table salt and even sea salt are not real salt. Typically they are mined, heated, stripped of minerals, infused with chemicals and bleached or, as is the case with some sea salt, taken from an ocean that is polluted.

The healthiest salt options, recognized by the body as the sodium chloride it needs, are either Real Salt or Himalayan Salt. Mined from ancient sea beds they remain untainted by toxins and provide a rich source of trace minerals.

Himalayan Salt is earning its reputation as a true health product with its whopping 84 trace minerals, plus a unique ionic energy that is released when the salt is mixed with water. "Himalayan Crystal Salt is salt in its native form, with all its vibrational energy intact and it helps promote a healthy balance in your body. Promoting balanced electrolytes helps to keep your body in homeostasis -- the balance of chemicals that is conducive to the body's function," says Joseph Mercola, D.O.

In Summary

The process of "refining" anything lowers its nutritional value and potentially makes it harmful, table salt is no different. Consider carefully before consuming anything that is processed because real is always going to be better than manufactured.


Dear Patient,
Dr. Cohn is dedicated to providing you with the absolute best in family wellness care. So take a moment today to discuss with your Family Wellness Chiropractor any concerns you may have regarding your family's overall health and wellness.

 This newsletter is provided to you by:

Dr. Ari Cohn
33 State Road, Suite B
Princeton, NJ 08540